Civilizational Engineering Research Institute

CER Institute

Appendix A

Civilizational Layer Index

CLI-12 Reference Document

CER Institute maintains a 12-Layer Civilizational Index (CLI-12).

CLI-12 is a classification and scoping framework used exclusively for:

  • analytical categorization
  • standards alignment
  • certification scope definition
  • cross-domain comparison

CLI-12 does not prescribe actions, does not define ideology, and does not authorize execution. It is a reference index only.

Principles of the Index

01

Descriptive, not ideological

It describes domains that exist in civilizational systems without promoting values, outcomes, or political positions.

02

Non-executing

The index confers no operational authority and mandates no behavior.

03

Non-hierarchical in UI

Numerical ordering is used strictly for reference and consistency, not prioritization.

04

Protocol-agnostic

The index does not assume any specific technology, platform, or implementation.

05

Stable across time

Definitions are written to remain valid across decades, independent of trends.

CLI-12 Layer Definitions

Each layer defines a domain of concern, not an implementation.

01.Foundational Law

Scope

Authority structures, legitimacy sources, and governing constraints that define what actions are permissible within a system.

Includes

  • constitutional principles
  • sources of authority
  • mandate boundaries
  • legitimacy and accountability mechanisms

Excludes

  • operational policy
  • enforcement tooling
  • execution procedures

02.Identity Systems

Scope

Mechanisms by which entities are identified, authenticated, and granted or revoked consent.

Includes

  • identity representation
  • authentication methods
  • consent models
  • revocation and expiry

Excludes

  • social profiles
  • reputation systems
  • engagement or influence metrics

03.Accounting & Ledger Systems

Scope

Methods for recording events, ownership, time, and provenance.

Includes

  • record-keeping models
  • temporal accounting
  • auditability
  • traceability

Excludes

  • markets
  • speculation mechanisms
  • exchange interfaces

04.Governance Structures

Scope

Decision-making models and institutional role definitions.

Includes

  • decision authority distribution
  • oversight mechanisms
  • escalation paths
  • role separation

Excludes

  • community voting UX
  • political campaigning
  • popularity-based control

05.Computation & Intelligence

Scope

Use of computation, automation, and artificial intelligence within governed systems.

Includes

  • AI system classification
  • automation boundaries
  • compute governance
  • human-machine responsibility division

Excludes

  • anthropomorphic framing
  • speculative intelligence claims
  • autonomous authority attribution

06.Network & Connectivity

Scope

Infrastructure enabling communication and coordination between entities.

Includes

  • communication layers
  • resilience and redundancy
  • access constraints
  • failure tolerance

Excludes

  • content platforms
  • social graphs
  • engagement optimization

07.Economic Structures

Scope

Systems governing production, allocation, and exchange of resources.

Includes

  • production models
  • allocation rules
  • exchange constraints
  • incentive structures

Excludes

  • marketing systems
  • growth narratives
  • speculative behavior framing

08.Education & Knowledge Transmission

Scope

Mechanisms for transferring knowledge, skills, and standards across time.

Includes

  • curricula structures
  • certification logic
  • assessment frameworks
  • institutional learning models

Excludes

  • entertainment content
  • influencer education
  • engagement-driven learning UX

09.Food & Resource Systems

Scope

Biological and material resource provisioning systems.

Includes

  • food production
  • water systems
  • biological cycles
  • sustainability constraints

Excludes

  • branding of consumption
  • lifestyle framing
  • culinary media

10.Energy & Thermal Systems

Scope

Energy generation, conversion, storage, and thermal management.

Includes

  • energy sources
  • conversion processes
  • storage models
  • efficiency and loss considerations

Excludes

  • market speculation
  • consumer gadget framing
  • promotional sustainability claims

11.Security & Risk Management

Scope

Protection against failure, harm, and systemic risk.

Includes

  • safety models
  • resilience planning
  • risk assessment
  • enforcement boundaries

Excludes

  • militarized language
  • fear-based UX
  • surveillance-driven narratives

12.Execution & Operations

Scope

Disciplined deployment, maintenance, and continuity of systems.

Includes

  • operational discipline
  • maintenance cycles
  • continuity planning
  • failure recovery

Excludes

  • project marketing
  • roadmap visualizations
  • motivational framing

This document is provided as a static reference. Numerical ordering is used for consistency and citation purposes only and does not imply hierarchy, priority, or sequence. The CLI-12 framework is not a roadmap, journey model, lifecycle diagram, or ecosystem visualization.